|
|
The
Matside View by Gary Abbott
Wrestling thoughts
from the NCAA Convention
Content:
Colleges that
don't sponsor wrestling.
Preserving Olympic Sports.
Gender Equity
Seminar.
Wrestling is a NCAA Sport.
I
was blessed to attend my first NCAA Convention this weekend, which
was held in the Gaylord Opryland Hotel and Convention Center in
Nashville, Tenn. As a wrestling person from the outside, I found the
event fascinating.. This was a collection of the movers and shakers
within the college sports community, coming together to work on
planning and direction for college athletics.
The main reason for USA Wrestling's attendance this year was a
special seminar entitled "Protecting Student-Athlete Opportunities:
The future of Olympic Sport Sponsorship at NCAA Institutions."
Coverage of this event has been posted on TheMat.com. We were also
able to attend a Title IX presentation, clearly a very important
topic to our sport and to our membership.
Here are a few random thoughts from a wrestling guy at this event:
The size of this convention is massive.
The convention area was large and expansive, as up to a reported
1,600 college administrators from all levels of the NCAA family
converged on Nashville. Clearly, the big local news in Nashville was
the NFL playoff game between New England and Tennessee up in frozen
Massachusetts, but once you got into the NCAA Convention, you
wouldn't know there was anything going on in the outside world. |
Home.
About Us.
FAQ's.
Timeline.
Tools.
$250 Essay
Competition.
Articles.
Clearinghouse.
College
Recruiting.
NCAA
Recruiting.
NCAA Sports
History.
Resources.
Sports History.
What do I send
to the coach.
How do I
contact the
coach.
|
|
|
They published this huge map
and schedule for each participant, who needed directions in order to get
to each meeting on time. They placed volunteers in referee's shirts to
help attendees find their way through the maze.
The sad thing to see were administrators from so many
colleges that do not
sponsor wrestling. It hurt even more to note all of the institutional
leaders from schools that used to have wrestling teams. In many cases,
the people here were not the ones that made the decision to kill off our
sport., as it happened before their time. However, in some cases, they
certainly are those people. And, these are the people, who, for whatever
reasons (such as Title IX) are not adding new wrestling teams to college
athletics. Of course, it has to feel even worse for Dick Aronson, the
gymnastics leader, who has seen his sport for men drop down to just 20
programs. He has pushed the NCAA for years to do something about
preserving Olympic sports opportunities. The seminar this weekend was a
result of Dick's efforts, along with other sports leaders who just want
to scream "STOP" to all of these dropped sports programs.
|
One of the wrestling leaders that I did see was the legendary
Bruce Baumgartner, the athletic director at Edinboro Univ. and the
past president of USA Wrestling. He and some other sports officials
from Edinboro were here to participate in the meetings. Athletic
directors are the hands-on administrators of college sports, and
there certainly needs to be more wrestling people like Bruce in
these positions of authority. We have a few out there (Andy Noel at
Cornell, Bob Carlson at Clarion, Rick Bay at San Diego State, etc.),
but clearly not enough.
* The turnout for the "Preserving Olympic Sports" session was
acceptable, but not very large. The key positive outcome from this
meeting was that the statements and discussions were on the public
record, and will hopefully appear in the next NCAA News. The next
session after the Olympic Sports discussion was the one on "Gender
Equity," and that program was jammed with people. I wonder if those
on the Olympic sports panel might have been preaching to the choir
to people who were already devoted to the Olympic sports movement.
It seemed to me that those in the "Gender Equity" session might have
been the ones who needed to hear from speakers talking about
preserving sports opportunities.
* Jim Scherr of the USOC did a tremendous job of presenting the
reasons that college athletics is so important to the Olympic
movement. He also had the courage to mention the possible negative
future effect of proportionality on men's Olympic sports
opportunities. The USOC has proposed a joint task force with the
NCAA to address these issues, which is a great idea that really
needs to be put into place right away. Another of the speakers, Ohio
State AD Andy Geiger, gave a motivational talk about the value of
all sports, including the Olympic sports, as part of the educational
process. If more people in positions of power had the passion and
commitment to all athletics like Geiger, we would not have to talk
about "endangered" Olympic sports at all. The sad truth is few
colleges have the financial advantages of an Ohio State, and face
tougher choices with their programs.
* The one downer during the Olympic sports meeting was the
presentation by Christine Grant of the Univ. of Iowa, who used
statistics from the discredited GAO study, as well as from the NCAA,
to try to claim that men have not lost opportunities in NCAA sports.
There is still a core group of people from the quota advocate groups
who keep trying to say that there is no problem concerning the loss
of opportunity for men. By refusing to admit that there is challenge
by using misleading statistics, they can continue to push forward
with the proportionality quota. Grant also asserts that there has
been an explosive spending increase on football and basketball, that
is choking off opportunity for the "so-called men's minor sports."
If her numbers in that area are even close to accurate, they provide
a damning indictment of the priorities of today's athletic
administrators which bodes poorly for the future of Olympic sports.
* The gender equity seminar was opened by an assistant athletic
director at Washington State, Marcia Saneholz, who reported on the
"success" of her school in meeting Title IX goals. The state has
supported tuition waivers for women's athletics, which has made it
easier for that school to build their women's athletics. However, a
large part of her presentation was a strong backlash against the
efforts for Title IX reform during the past year. At least she was
not one of the phonies - she asserted that it should be expected for
men to "give" something up in order to eliminate past
discrimination, as if the slashing was right and fair. As with
others on the women's sports side of things, they continue to lump
the victims from sports like wrestling and gymnastics with those in
men's basketball and football. We are all men, after all. We all
know that the only ones giving up their opportunities are those in
the Olympic sports, certainly not hoopsters and football players.
Once again, she and others kept tooting the horn of NCAA President
Myles Brand, who has bought into the gender quota position and was a
powerful force to kill the momentum for Title IX reform a year ago.
Brand has become a hero to the quota advocates.
* Speaking of NCAA President Myles Brand, there was an incident
during the Saturday evening reception that was a bit embarrassing.
With over a thousand people jammed into a large hall, he was brought
up to the podium to say a few words. However, the sound system was
terrible, and the noise from the people talking in the crowd was
tremendous, and absolutely nobody heard a word that he said. There
was the most powerful person in college athletics on a stage talking
to himself, with nobody paying attention. Certainly, the free food
and drink played a factor in this&
* I had a discussion with Ed Matejkovic, the athletic director at
West Chester University, which recently has been embroiled in a
Title IX legal matter. He commented on how he has been dealing with
Title IX challenges, like the wrestling community. West Chester
dropped a number of sports teams recently, including one women's
team (gymnastics). An outside group on behalf of the women gymnasts
took the matter to court, and a judge has ruled that West Chester
had to reinstate its women's gymnastics team (but not the men's
teams). He noted that West Chester truly believes it is in
compliance with the law, but it is not exactly in proportionality,
and that was the only factor that the judge considered. He said the
university has appealed the decision, and is in on-going
negotiations concerning the next step in the process. West Chester
did not cave into the legal pressure, like the Univ. of Northern
Iowa did recently when it reversed a decision to drop women's and
men's teams, bringing back just the women.
* It was the week of the NCAA Convention that the NCAA chose to
release its Gender Equity study for the 2001-02 years. It ran on
page one of the NCAA News handed out at the convention, and was one
of the lead stories on the NCAA web page. The headline for the
article is "Data show continued gender gap in spending." Again,
there was no mention of the affect on participation for men's
Olympic sports, so I will have to download the document to see what
the numbers say about what happened to us. If you didn't think there
is a focus on the proportionality quota, you need to read this
article. The word "proportion" was mentioned 30 times in the story,
and the word "percent" was used 57 times.
* I kept an eye out for any references to wrestling in the NCAA
literature and propoganda. There were many displays, posters and
banners all over the convention site. The NCAA has a large and
effective public relations presence. There was a poster on
nutrition, which, predictably, featured an image of wrestling. It
showed Cael Sanderson against Jon Trenge in the 2002 NCAA finals.
The quote on the poster said "Doing my best doesn't mean winning at
any cost." There were also some photos of wrestling on other
displays. The "National Championships" display had four larger
photos along with many smaller sports images. One of the four big
images was a picture of Matt Lackey of Illinois celebrating his win
at last year's NCAA tournament (the other sports prominently
featured were women's basketball, women's lacrosse and men's
soccer).
* The NCAA took over Channel 29 on the hotel television system, and
ran its commercials and other videos on the channel all weekend. Of
the 24 different shows and commercial spots, there were none
specifically about wrestling. They showed all of those national
public service announcements that you see on television all the
time. The sports highlighted in them were women's swimming, men's
shot put, softball, men and women's basketball and water polo. I
left the television on during the weekend, hoping to see some
wrestling on the NCAA channel. I did not. There was a monitor on
during the reception which showed a few wrestling highlights, but it
was the only time during the weekend that I saw any wrestling video.
* There needs to be a push for the NCAA and the USOC to do an awards
program, honoring the top Olympic sports athletes on the college
level. The NCAA does a tremendous job with its "Woman of the Year"
awards (there is no Man of the Year award as far as I can tell). The
Olympic sports need the same kind of support, and a big-time award,
with a number of featured finalists each year, would provide some
tremendous and needed publicity for the amazing athletes from the
Olympic sports.
* Wrestling is an NCAA sport, and college athletics is very
important to our Olympic effort. It seems to me that wrestling needs
to be more prominent with this group of individuals, the people
making decisions about sports offerings in college. It did not seem
to me that wrestling is a player in this community, and that could
be another reason that our sport has suffered so many losses.
Please take the time to check out the
rest of our website for more detailed information about the baseball
recruiting process and applying for a sports scholarship.
SCHOLARSHIP INFORMATION
Baseball I
Basketball I
Bowling I
Cross Country I
Fencing I
Field Hockey I
Football I
Golf I
Gymnastics I
Ice
Hockey
Lacrosse I
Rowing I
Skiing I
Soccer I
Softball I
Swimming
I Tennis I
Track
and Field
Volleyball I
Water
Polo I Wrestling
© College
Sports Scholarships
Contact the Webmaster
The first thing Jamie
Moffatt wants to make clear is that he is not trying to trash Title
IX. But he firmly believes
Title IX is broken and needs to be
repaired.
"These are perilous times," said Brand. "The
future of Title IX is uncertain.
We do not know what Secretary Paige will do with the recommendations of
the Commission on Opportunity in Athletics."
When it comes to cutting men's track programs, West Virginia is hardly
alone. In the last few years, universities such as St. John's, Tulane,
Vermont, Toledo and Bowling Green have all
axed their men's track teams.
Title IX improving the
application of current Federal standards for measuring equal
opportunity."
Part 1
Women enjoy a distinct advantage over men in college athletics.
Part 2
Bakke
believed that his rejections were in direct violation of the Equal
Protection Clause of the 14th amendment.
Part 3
Football seems to be the
issue when dealing with scholarships. A school is permitted 85 scholarships
for football.
Part 4
When Title IX was created it was crafted with intent to make it easy for
schools to comply with its guidelines.
Part 5
For the
first time since 1968, the USA freestyle wrestlers failed to win a single
gold medal.
Part 6
Every
college is required to have a designated Title IX coordinator.
Part 7
Over 110,000
women participated in intercollegiate sports. Where as in 1971 just about
25,000 participated.
Maintaining a stress-resistant lifestyle, within reason, can also
help keep you healthy. Limit alcohol and eat right. Enjoy a few
treats but don't forget your vegetables. Get enough rest and plenty
of exercise. Remember, too, that perfectionism is stressful.
Holidays excuse some indulgence, so don't forget to enjoy.
|